Fri, 07/21/2017 - 08:48

Posted by Tamara Baluja on October 09, 2013

Postmedia Network’s B.C. papers have suffered a spate of bad news recently—a large number of employees took buyouts from The Province and the Vancouver Sun, and there were rumours the two brands would be merged into one newspaper. Then there was that memo from Pacific News Group president Gordon Fisher that riled many, putting two floors of its building up for lease and the sale of its B.C. printing plant.

“PNG has been in the news in Vancouver this year for a variety of, shall I say, wrong reasons,” The Province’s editor-in-chief Wayne Moriarty told J-Source.

Now, the two newspapers want to “reset” the conversation. Collectively, 86 per cent of Lower Mainland adults read the Sun and The Province every month. That’s a 10.3 per cent increase from a year ago, according to statistics in an editorial note Moriarty wrote.

Related content on J-Source:

“Project Reset is essentially a step back from all the doom and gloom in order to look realistically at the situation,” Moriarty said to J-Source. “Yes, we are going through significant changes, but our overall readership is growing and the health of these businesses, while not ideal, is sound. Nothing Pollyanna about this, just fact-based reality intended to make employees and our customers feel good about where we are at and where we are going.” 

Fisher said the idea for Project Reset started percolating in the early summer as PNG geared up for the start of the fiscal year in the fall. “There was so much negativity about not only our newspapers but also the industry, and we needed to change that conversation.”

The newspaper solicited feedback from advertisers and its employees.

“Some of the employee feedback was quite sobering … many of them wondered if we had a strategy going forward for success,” Fisher said.

“I can absolutely, 100 per cent put to rest that idea that the Sun and The Province are merging,” he said. “And we absolutely do have a very plan going forward.”

Fisher said the newspapers will have platform-specific champions and changes will come to the digital and print editions in 2014. “We’ve been guilty of just copying and pasting the same content on all the platforms, when we now know that isn’t the best approach,” he said.

At the Sun, web editor Aleesha Harris will be the new tablet champion and sports editor Scott Brown will become the new mobile champion. Meanwhile, digital managing editor Gillian Burnett will expand her role to become the web/desktop champion and deputy managing editor Adrienne Tanner will be the print champion. Bev Wake, the city editor, will be the central figure coordinating all the different platforms; she doesn’t have a formal job title yet, but editor-in-chief Harold Munro said that role is being called the “maestro” for now.

While not every story will make it to each platform, it’s the platform champions who will take charge of how the printed product will feature on the other platforms. “The print product will be most strongly aligned to what the reporters are doing, and then the platform champions will mould it to the specific platform,” Munro told J-Source.

Fisher said in addition to these changes, the management has made a commitment to communicate more often with staff through town halls on business updates and also to be more visible generally. “We need to make that part of our culture and say we’re all in this together,” he said.

While not minimizing the challenges facing most newspapers—that print revenue is declining at a faster rate than digital revenue can catch up—he feels confident a solution is at hand.

“We did a survey of advertisers and they still have confidence in the brands of these two newspapers and say we’re the best at getting their message out,” he said. “The issue is that there are so many other avenues for them to advertise through, so they’re spreading their resources out. The challenge, then, for us is convincing them we’re still the best choice.”


The Sun and Province remind me of penny stocks on Howe Street whose steady supply of upbeat press releases only dries up when they hang up the bankruptcy sign.

Got a problem with your readers? Heck no -- 86% of Lower Mainlanders read our papers! Up 10% from last year! We've never been so popular!

No wait. We're still losing money.

If we have a problem, it sure doesn't lie with management, head office, the staff or the product. No sir. All of the above -- first rate.

We're loved all right. Now we just need to show them how lucky they are to have us.

So just like Enbridge and its pipeline of horrors, the only thing standing between Pacific Media and a revival of the glory days is a good PR campaign. Let's call it Project Reset. Now to do some more polling ...

The simple fact is that the Sun and Province are both expensive, run on old-fashioned industrial models and, worse, are becoming increasingly irrelevant. I don't need the Sun to lecture me on wearing a helmet when I snowboard, and talking up the real estate market is just makes me want to turn the page in search of some real news.

The viral video that concerned thousands of Sun's  readers -- Speed Kills Your Pocketbook -- was out for over a month and had 1.2 million hits before it was covered in the Sun. The video was made in Vancouver and concerned a province-wide issue.

And yet, somehow the newspaper has no end of space for Telus and its never-ending good charitable works. I'm all in favour of charity. I just think newspapers that suck up to big advertisers like Telus don't deserve to survive, and probably won't.

Here's a radical idea. How about resetting the newsroom?



Despite the "reset," the Vancouver Sun's Saturday edition produced yet another story on Telus's wondrous charitable works, surely top of mind when it comes to what Vancouverites want in a newspaper. Isn't public relations great? All talk, no action.


J-Source and ProjetJ are publications of the Canadian Journalism Project, a venture among post-secondary journalism schools and programs across Canada, led by Ryerson University, Université Laval and Carleton University and supported by a group of donors.